What “Third-Party Laboratory” Actually Tells You

What “third-party” means

In testing, the first party is the producer, the second party the buyer or customer, and the third party an independent organisation. A third-party laboratory is an independent business commissioned to test the product. It has no stake in whether the results are good or bad, which is why third-party testing is generally preferred to in-house testing for safety results.

What it adds

• IndependenceThe laboratory doesn’t sell the product.
• Professional methodsUsually specialist equipment and procedures.
• A named organisationWhose report can be checked.

What it doesn’t tell you

A claim vs a report

“Third-party lab tested” on a label is a claim. A third-party laboratory’s report, naming the laboratory, batch and results, is evidence. A brand making the claim should be able to provide the report; see “lab tested” claims and how to ask for a COA.

Limits to independence

A third-party laboratory is independent in its analysis, but it tests what it is sent. The brand chooses the sample and the tests, and pays the laboratory. That isn’t a reason to distrust third-party results, but it is why independent retail testing adds a different kind of check; see independent vs brand-provided COAs.

An example

Nature Elixirs’ batch SJ2509 was tested by AGROLAB LUFA, an independent laboratory in Germany stating ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation. The published report names the batch, sample, dates and results across a broad panel.^[2] That combination of third-party, accreditation, batch and results is what turns “third-party tested” into usable evidence. Nature Elixirs is a brand evaluated by Best Shilajit UK. Read our evaluation to see the evidence and documentation we reviewed.

Check ownership if unfamiliar

Occasionally, a laboratory described as third-party is linked to a supplier. If the laboratory is unfamiliar, a quick search for its owner and accreditation helps; see laboratories on UK COAs.

Follow-up questions

1. Which laboratory?Name and location.
2. Is it accredited for these tests?See what accreditation tells you.
3. Can I see the report for my batch?
4. Which tests were included?

In-house testing explained

In-house testing means the brand or its supplier tests the product in its own laboratory. It can be useful for routine checks during production, such as moisture or appearance, and some in-house laboratories are well equipped. But for safety results that buyers rely on, an independent laboratory removes the question of whether the tester has an interest in the outcome.

How the phrase is used in marketing

“Third-party tested” has become a common marketing phrase, sometimes used without a report to back it up. Treat it like any claim: ask for the evidence. A brand that genuinely uses third-party testing will happily name the laboratory and share the report for your batch.

Putting it into practice

When you see “third-party tested”, ask four questions: which laboratory, is it accredited for these tests, which batch was tested, and can you see the report? If the answers are clear and the report is full, the claim means something. If not, it is just a phrase.

Second-party testing

Sometimes a retailer or distributor, rather than the brand, commissions testing. That is sometimes called second-party testing. It adds a different perspective, because the retailer has its own reputation at stake, but it still involves a commercial interest in the product. As with any test, the report itself is what matters.

In short

“Third-party” describes who did the testing. Accreditation describes how well they can do it. The report describes what they found, and the batch number tells you whether it applies to your jar.

Checking a laboratory’s independence

Most third-party laboratories are established independent businesses, and their websites describe their ownership and services. If a laboratory is unfamiliar, searching its name, address and accreditation number usually confirms its independence within a few minutes. If you can’t find it at all, ask the brand for more detail before relying on the report. A genuine laboratory is always easy to find and contact, and most will confirm whether they issued a report.

The bottom line

“Third-party laboratory” tells you the testing was independent of the brand. It doesn’t tell you about accreditation, the tests, the sample or the results. Ask for the laboratory’s report for your batch, and judge that.

Related reading